From a recorded Inquiry session of a five day retreat. Retreatant comes to sit next to me in the Dharma hall. Dialogue gets underway. A meditation on listening for retreatants. This is a transcription with modest editing, tweaking for readability. I offer a reflection at the end of the 1-1.
Q: I started meditating much more intensively at the beginning of the year than I had before, and I’ve been reading a lot. The subject that comes up often is what to do with an emerging thought. Do I entertain it, allow it to become symbolic, attach language to it, or just dismiss it?
CT: It’s a regular question. It’s one of those questions that doesn’t have a yes to this and a no to that. A thought may arise, and you allow it. You give it an opportunity to express itself. It provides some further clarity.

If you keep a mindful eye on the thought, you might notice that it’s going in a direction that isn’t very helpful or useful. It could be the start of going around in circles. You exaggerate or undermine a situation. If you see that happening, practice to let go of the thought. It is occupying space in the mind—especially circular thinking, going over something that you know full well you’ve gone over before, probably repeatedly.
A fresh thought will communicate itself to you. You allow more time for it to unfold.
Q: I’m often forced to deal with thoughts that aren’t particularly comfortable.
CT: Such as…
Q: Things from the past and assessments of situations. I know they’re important because they keep coming back. I do not keep feeding them or entertaining them. They just keep coming up in the background of day-to-day life. I’ve learned to recognise them and think, “Okay, this is that issue”.
Does the fact that a thought keeps coming up, particularly with my kids or my past situations tell me I should deal with it? Should I get curious about these thoughts or leave them alone?
CT: The view may arise: “Thoughts keep coming up; therefore, they are important.” That’s much too big a step to take. Thoughts might just keep coming up because you have the habit of thinking too much. Thoughts may not have anything of great significance whatsoever. It might be a simple habit. If the mind is in a certain condition—tiredness, restlessness or boredom—thoughts can quickly emerge.
An issue keeps arising that seems to say, “This needs attention.” Take credit for trying to catch thoughts early. Look at what is forming in the words. That might really be requiring some attention. It could be about your kids, your work, yourself, or whatever. What is the formation of language including attitude embedded in the thoughts?
An issue may need attention to find a change of view. The inner life can either push the issue away as a reaction, an act of the will, or it keeps re-emerging because it’s calling on you to say, “This needs attention.”
Attention is the first step. It’s not the answer or the solution. In that first step of giving attention, the next step questions “What do I need to see clearly here? What confirms a meaningful change? What do I need to understand? Do I need to share my experience with a trustworthy person?”
We have a whole army and network of people listening to others and offering responses: counsellors, therapists, mindfulness teachers and many others.
Interest and inquiry accompany attention. Any response?
Q: I haven’t had access to a therapist, as many of us often do. Do I have a problem with acceptance. What steps do I take to increase acceptance?
CT: The language of acceptance gets used a lot in spiritual and therapy circles. It’s used repeatedly: “Oh, I really have to accept myself. I really have to accept my past. I really have to accept this issue” The belief that acceptance resolves challenging situations shows delusion in the mind.
You need insight and understanding. The place for acceptance follows from your beneficial insights and understanding. You look at a situation; something keeps coming up. Relying on acceptance at the beginning insults your intelligence. Instead, you say, “I’m not accepting this. I’m going to look at it and see the necessary change. What do I need to understand? What do I need to be clear about?”
When you know clarity and understanding, you accept that. That is the place of acceptance. This teaching comes straight out of the Buddha’s Dharma. He only used acceptance as a fruit as an outcome of wisdom and the compassion. Acceptance without love and understanding reveals a weak mind, passive and not enduring.
Would you like to give an example of something that keeps coming up and needs attention, but hasn’t been resolved? If you wish to share….
Q: Yes. I feel that I should have done two or three things fundamentally differently. They were mistakes—two roads, and I took the wrong one. I was deluded about a lot of things at the time. It is crystal clear now what the right thing to do was. I so regret.
CT: Regret is healthy. It’s guilt that’s the problem. That’s another area. I’m not too concerned with the content of which direction was the wrong road. What I’m more interested in is what happened when you woke up and saw that you were on the wrong road. What made you realise that I must change my direction in life?
Q: The profession I had prepared for, I attached a large part of my identity to. I had borrowed a large sum of money, spent much time, and tons of effort. I should have just said, “I can’t,” and stopped. I had the requisite knowledge from my training to know it just wasn’t going to go anywhere. The decision to try to find a work around failed to work. I ended up having to stop that profession. I got beaten down. All the effort was futile in the first place . That was the lesson: it was never going to work; it never could have worked. The attempt to force the impossible was futile and foolish.
CT: You engaged in a specific work environment, a profession, with years of training, and then doubts came in. You couldn’t continue with the profession any longer. Sometimes the road ends in darkness. Did you know where you ended? What happened?
Q: I would say I did.
CT: Good spirit. What marks the difference between the old road and the road you’re on now?
Q: A combination of acceptance and creativity.
CT: Acceptance and creativity?
Q: I’ll expand on that. Accepting my limitations allows me to be creative and find ways to help other people who have the same type of problem so they can manage it better than I did.
CT: That’s a genuinely precious kind of learning. Sometimes creative ways to support others comes out of raw, naked experience, including the anguish. The person knows the anguish that goes along with the end of the road. Bringing such a consciousness to a halt, an outcome shows the raw experience supports and protects them from ending up somewhere they never wanted to be.
Q: Will they listen?
CT: The best way to encourage people to listen comes through the love you show. Don’t tell them, warn them or pressure them. Love builds trust for those on the dark road much often travelled by many. Your kindness will contribute to their response. Yes, capacity to listen. That’s the power of love.
Q: Thank you. Thank you.
A Reflection.
CT: Let’s have a couple of quiet minutes, and then I’ll give a short reflection.
Inner listening informs us about areas we need to develop. The Buddha referred to the the five hindrances. A hindrance hinders love, clarity, and waking up; it gets in the way of wisdom and liberation.
First is greed: excess wanting, dependency on results, and attraction—the pull towards something, sometimes compellingly.
Second is aversion, negative reactivity. Anger, aggression.
Third is boredom, dullness, apathy, and indifference, also impacting on our mental well-being.
Fourth is restlessness: physical restlessness and emotional anxiety, often bringing in the future, includes speculations, excessive thinking, views and worries.
Fifth combines fear and doubt. Sometimes fear and doubt inhibit us and hold us back.
We learn about our greatest vulnerabilities. Do I need to give extra care and attention so that I’m as ready as I possibly can be when one or more of those hindrances arises?
It seems hard to make up one’s mind. It’s almost as if there are two currents of thought in conflict. Though we like to say, “I chose this one,” it could be that the one we ‘choose’ because we thought more about one than the other. It could be that we reacted to the one we thought about too much, so we went for the other choice.
We don’t like to admit that, so we say, “I finally made a choice,” to impress ourselves or others. The language of choice could be the language of self-deceit.
With these dualities, vigilance becomes necessary. Excessive think does not help us to make up our mind. Such thinking takes up a lot of energy becomes mentally tiring. Tired of thinking, we find ourselves less able to respond and act clearly. A thought is a unit of energy. Mental tiredness gets into the system and impacts elsewhere. Let’s be guardian angels in our relationship to thought.
Thoughts may involve the language of path, goal, journey or the spiritual life, A person walks the path., Whispers within arise. “This isn’t leading anywhere. The path does not take me where I want to go.” A person may feel sad, paralysed, unable to get out of a situation – imprisoned to feelings and thoughts. Wise counsel and support from others can act as a support to wake up and make a change.
Unable to change your view, a situation seems overwhelming weighing heavily on you, blocking your freedom to explore something new.
Reflect on difficult situations from the past when you had the same thought: “I can’t make up my mind. I don’t know if I’ll get through this. This is too big to handle.” One way or another, you moved through it, got past it, and found a new rhythm to your life.
If you can remember two or three challenging situations that you got through, then you have authority to say to yourself and others “I got through those last two or three situations that really had an impact. I’ll get through this one, too.” We need the empowerment of the past to give us trust and confidence that we can work through the current crisis.
Even when we’re moving in a fine direction in life, it’s often two steps forward and one step back. Sometimes it’s two steps forward and three steps back. When we take those three steps back, we need to remember: “Look, I took two steps forward.” Find ways to keep expanding and moving in a wise direction in life.
Draw upon the voice of others. It’s a myth that truth is only found within you. Truth is that which transforms. Who cares where it comes from? Human, non-human, natural world, a book, God, out of the blue. Sometimes truth comes from a deep inner voice, from the voice of another. Listen to their words, their endorsement of us; listen to their faith in us. We need somebody else to say to us, “You’re right. Go ahead and let go of what does not work for you. Go ahead and walk down a new road.”
Once that action begins to take place, you know the truth has touched you. Truth is transformative; the rest of our mind consists of endless views. Truth and views reveal a world of difference—a big difference. We’re interested in truth. Constant views tire the mind..
Enough. Thanks for listening. Let’s have a quiet minute together.
www.thebuddhawallah.org (hub website outlining five other websites).

